Frequently Asked Questions

---

 Grab a spoon! Seriously, we find that most folks eat our peanut butter straight out of the jar with a spoon. Some flavors can be spread on toast, dipped with graham crackers, made into protein balls, etc... but most of our flavors are more like an edible cookie dough than a jar of grocery-store peanut butter. If you're looking for a spreadable peanut butter, stick with our base flavors (Creamy, Crunchy, Galaxy Grape, Rockin Raspberry). Any flavors with marshmallow fluff, caramel sauce, Oreo's, or frosting will be thicker and drier than traditional peanut butter. 

 We mix each small batch by hand and blend ingredients all throughout your butter. All flavors also have extra toppings placed on top as well! 

Most of our flavors are besides our Cookies N Cream. Unfortunately, some manufacturers don't claim that their products are gluten free for liability reasons (even though they likely are gluten free). Because of this, we cannot claim gluten free on some of our products. We advise you to closely examine the nutrition facts which can be found in the photos on each product page. 

You'll find a little of everything with us. Some of our flavors are creamy and can be spread and some of our flavors are like cake batter and can be eaten with a spoon. As we say, Dunk It, Spread It, Scoop it!

 Our handcrafted peanut butters do not need refrigerated. Some flavors like Galaxy Grape and Rockin Raspberry should be refrigerated by manufacturer standards. 

 Unopened products will remain fresh for 6 months. Once opened, we recommend eating within 30 days (but let's be honest, does it really last that long anyway?). 

It is common to see oil on top of natural peanut butters. Some flavors gain more oil than others depending on the consistency and mix-ins. 

It is common to see oil on top of natural peanut butters. Some flavors gain more oil than others depending on the consistency and mix-ins. 

 Oh no! We try our best but mistakes happen. Please email us and we will make it right. 

 Unfortunately, as a small batch company, we cannot accept returns or exchanges and all sales are final. We work hard to strive for customer satisfaction and we're happy to replace your product with another flavor for the cost of shipping a new jar to you. 

 We ship all of our products out of our small-batch kitchen in Columbia, New Jersey. 

 All of our peanut butter products are made fresh daily. While we strive to get orders out within 1-3 business days, your order may take 5-7 business days to ship. As a small batch peanut butter company, we do not have a warehouse with shelves full of finished products. Once we fulfill your order and it ships, you will receive an email notification with tracking information. 

 We wish it was cheaper too! Unfortunately, peanut butter is heavy and expensive to ship. What we charge you to ship your product is often less than what we actually pay.